Who does not know that the first law of historical writing is the truth-Cicero The writings of Daniel Louis Duncan
Historical Genealogy
This blog will act as my own genealogical sharing and as a working site for client research. Please feel free to write with your genealogical questions. I will try to help lead you in the right direction and tell you when it is time to hire some help.
More places to find my writing:
twitter: @DanielLouisDun1 https://thatsjhiroll.blogspot.com/
contact: rousseauman@yahoo.com
Featured Post
The death of a Great Historian leads me to ask "Where did he come from? What was his muse?"
"[B]inary opposites fit nicely the formulation of history as written, but they do little to capture the messy, inchoate reality of h...
Tuesday, November 28, 2017
You just can't look away!
Ancestry.com is on a marketing binge! Their new app "We're Related" has been out for a while now. At first I just laughed as some of the ludicrous leaps that were made to show how I was related to celebrities of all shapes and sizes. Most, up until recently, I could discount right away as they are plugging in mother connections for several generations that just don't vibe. I just could not find proof of any connection. Not a good marketing tool for Ancestry credibility. But, I tried to look through the muck and see if anything vibed.
When they started to get a bit closer in cousin connections I started to do some investigating. Right here and now I'll say I'm not too happy😞. Ok...I was happy with Elvis, Jimmy Carter, James Dean, Brad Pitt, and Kate Blanchett, all of whom seem to line up with my research, yet distant relations.
I grew up in the south so I prepared myself, somewhat, for what surprise "ding" I would get. There it was.....Newt Gingrich and Ann Coulter. Crap! That just cannot be. Then, I reminded myself that ideology is not necessarily inherited or passed down😩. My immediate family, for the most part, were conservative republicans, except for Pappa, my step great grandfather. Somehow, even though I was raised by my grandparents, I ended up mostly a radical, liberal, socialist, etc... I hate labels, so if you must...pick one. My bio mom was progressive to say the least, which gave her mother great consternation. I'm still grappling with her extreme IQ and mental illness and just how wrong her life has been treated. I digress....
So, Newtie isn't Newt. Turns out he changed his name and he's possibly my 6th cousin, 2xs removed on my mother's father's German side.😮 One of my projects, that I need to jump into more now, is on a Civil War Union soldier from PA, my 2nd great grandfather, and his wife who was a nurse in the Civil War in PA. My connection to Newt is through this nurse's mother, Sarah Follmer. Her great grand father Hans Michael Follmer/Vollmar married Ragina Magdalena (last name unknown) my 7th great grandmother. Magdalena was used often in German heritage.
Ragina/Regina was born 18 Jun 1730 in Tulpehocken, Berks Co., PA and died 18 Aug 1813 in Milton, Northumberland Co., PA.
Regina Magdalena Follmer
Ragina/Regina and Hans Michael Follmer had Elizabeth Follmer (Newt's supposed 4th great grandmother) and Adam Follmer (my 6th great grandfather, thus 2xs removed). Elizabeth and Adam were brother and sister.
Now, Newt's real name is Newton5 (Newton Searles4, Clarence Newton3, James Silverwood2, William1) McPherson. From there his connection to me is through William McPherson's maternal line.
Ann Coulter is my direct 5th cousin. Deep breath....runs out of room screaming😖😒😱
My maternal grandmother's, who raised me as her own child, paternal grandmother was Amanda Nance.
Ann Coulter's mother was Nell Husbands Martin. Her mother was Nell Warner, who's mother was Nellie Nance, and our mutual Nance line begins.
Nellie Nance was the daughter of Joseph Monroe Nance who's father was Clement Nance.
Clement was the brother of Daniel Nance, my 3rd great grandfather. Making Ann Coulter and I direct 5th cousins. I need a drink....
Thursday, November 2, 2017
My Cousin Elvis is NOT a Presley! Well...yes he's a Presley, but he's also a Wallace.
So, my 7th cousin, Elvis is not a Presley! WHAT???
It turns out that Elvis may have two Native American lines in his genealogy. One is also my Tapp/Taptico line from the Chesapeake Bay area of Virginia, see my previous post on this line: DNA detective work and Advantages of knowing your past
Here's why Elvis is not really a Presley, but a Wallace!
Elvis Aaron Presley born 8 Jan 1935 and died 16 Aug 1977 in Tupelo, Lee County, MS.
Father: Vernon Elvis Presley born 10 Apr 1916 and died 26 Jun 1979 in Fulton, MS.
Grandfather: Jessie D. McDowell Presley born 9 Apr 1896 and died 19 Apr 1973.
Here's where the family tree diverges **Great Grandfather: John Henry Wallace born about Aug 1853 and died about Nov 1935 in Itawamba County, MS, had several children with Rosella Elizabeth Presley born 16 Feb 1861 and died 30 Jul 1924 in Fulton County, MS. The details of why these children took on the name of their mother is unclear and can be left for another bit of detail work later.
John Henry Wallace's mother, Elvis' great, great grandmother was Lydia Gideon. The marriage of Lydia Gideon and Hugh Henry Berry Wallace was 6 Oct 1852 in Itawamba, MS.
Lydia's mother was Elizabeth Tapp Gideon, Elvis' 3rd great grandmother (married John Gideon) born about 1794 and died about 1850. *This connection will involve more research on my part to find definitive proof, but the circumstantial evidence is compelling.
Elizabeth Tapp Gideon was the daughter of Moses Tapp, Elvis' 4th great grandfather, born about 1758 in Culpepper, VA and died about 1825 in Spartanburg, SC.
Moses Tapp was the son of Vincent Tapp (part of the DNA tested direct Taptico line), Elvis' 5th great grandfather, and Mary "Molly" Jett.
Vincent Tapp, the brother of my 5th great grandfather William Tapp IV, was the son of William Tapp III, Elvis and my 6th great grandfather!
William Tapp III was the son of the last Wicocomico Tribal chief, William Taptico II, named changed to Tapp on his will (well documented and now in history books, see previous post connections above).
This line is through my father's lineage. "Thank you! Thank you very much!"
Friday, October 27, 2017
Halloween Serendipity
It's Halloween time! I've been seeing references to one of my all time favorite actors and human beings, Vincent Price! I grew up, albeit, with a not so normal obsession with old horror movies and Edgar Allan Poe. Specifically anything Vincent Price did. He also had a love for Poe. So, like I always do, I decided to look up Mr. Price's family tree.
Vincent Leonard Price, Jr is the direct descendant of Rebecca Nurse of Salem, one of the women accused of witchcraft who lost her life to the hysteria of the time. Rebecca Towne Nurse was Vincent's 7th great grandmother! I wonder if he actually knew that! This is through his grandfather Vincent Clarence Price, who was the inventor of Dr. Price's Baking Powder, wife's line, Harriet Elizabeth White.
Here's the line: Vincent Leonard Price, Jr., Vincent Leonard Price, Sr., Vincent Clarence Price who married Harriet Elizabeth White
Harriet Elizabeth White, daughter of Russell Jesse White, Aaron White, Jr. who married Mary Bigelow
Mary Bigelow, daughter of Thomas Bigelow, Jedidiah Bigelow who married Thomasine Nurse
Thomasine Nurse, daughter of Benjamin Nurse, Jr., Benjamin Nurse, Sr. who's father Francis Nurse married Rebecca Towne (Rebecca Nurse accused Salem witch, 71 years of age, hanged on July 19, 1692). Rebecca was a central character in Arthur Miller's Crucible.
I have to believe Vincent Price didn't know of this, but of course, I can't be sure. Oh, how serendipitous!
Vincent Leonard Price, Jr is the direct descendant of Rebecca Nurse of Salem, one of the women accused of witchcraft who lost her life to the hysteria of the time. Rebecca Towne Nurse was Vincent's 7th great grandmother! I wonder if he actually knew that! This is through his grandfather Vincent Clarence Price, who was the inventor of Dr. Price's Baking Powder, wife's line, Harriet Elizabeth White.
Here's the line: Vincent Leonard Price, Jr., Vincent Leonard Price, Sr., Vincent Clarence Price who married Harriet Elizabeth White
Harriet Elizabeth White, daughter of Russell Jesse White, Aaron White, Jr. who married Mary Bigelow
Mary Bigelow, daughter of Thomas Bigelow, Jedidiah Bigelow who married Thomasine Nurse
Thomasine Nurse, daughter of Benjamin Nurse, Jr., Benjamin Nurse, Sr. who's father Francis Nurse married Rebecca Towne (Rebecca Nurse accused Salem witch, 71 years of age, hanged on July 19, 1692). Rebecca was a central character in Arthur Miller's Crucible.
I have to believe Vincent Price didn't know of this, but of course, I can't be sure. Oh, how serendipitous!
Wednesday, October 25, 2017
Wednesday, September 13, 2017
DNA Heritage Mapping
While I immerse myself in the DNA genealogy study, serendipity strikes really hard. I've been delving into heritage percentages and have found surprising results in a few areas, not surprising in others. Once and only once, for a week, I traveled to Spain. To this day I haven't left, in my mind and spirit. That sounds weird, I know. But, two strange things have happened in my life to scar me and touch my soul deeply. They came very unexpectedly.
First, was my trip to Spain in 1996, I believe. Dates, in my own life, sometimes evade me. Dead people, no problem! Spain moved me in ways that I still am trying to understand. It was easy to write the experience off to an American leaving their country for the first time. That should have explained a lot. But...it was much deeper I would find.
My time in Spain and Portugal was spent exploring. I have visited Santiago de Compostela and Fatima, two of the major holy places in the world. While these holy places were great, my experiences in both Spain and Portugal hold spiritual experiences I'm still trying to understand.
We'll stick to the ones in Spain, for now.
Spain did something to me. What, I still don't quite understand, but I believe DNA may be a large part of that. I could not explain why I, who could not speak a word of Spanish, besides perfunctory greetings, could communicate so well non-verbally with Spanish people. Not just that, but people were drawn to me for some odd reason. A feeling of these people being my relatives surged through my veins. It was odd!! Part of me was very freaked out, the other part was amazingly calm. If you know me, calm is not a place I visit often, so it's a big deal.
Fast forward to DNA testing. Once I became a better student of DNA findings I delved deeply into where all of my heritage could be broken down. Yep....a large swath, from far back, was all over Spain. All practically equally divided between Cataluna, Castilla y Leon, and Galicia. Galicia was were I visited and felt like I should have never left. Weird...huh?
The hard part is finding out who in my tree this comes from, even if that will be possible. Some surprises, some not. Here's my surprises: 1. Orkney Islands, off of Northern Scotland
2. Dutch, Norwegian and Swedish
The rest makes sense, I know where my French comes from, my Irish, my west Scottish, my German, Austrian, English, even the Native American.
I would suspect my Spain connection is through my early Virginia Chesapeake tribe that was documented as being different in complexion and culture than other natives encountered in other regions by the English.
The other experience is one I don't share because it's so text book "spiritual sighting", like seeing Jesus in my potato chip. In Lisbon, Portugal I was fortunate enough to take a monastery bus tour. This was stunning beyond words to be in cathedrals build in the 13th through 16th centuries, the tombs of Kings and Queens everywhere.
This area of Lisbon dates back to the "Discoveries". The time was exploratory travels to other worlds. The picture above is the monument to the discoveries in Lisbon. I went to the top and looked down on this map, which was quite extraordinary. Many of the landings in Native "America" are what blended Spanish, Portuguese, and even Dutch into the blood of the Native population all along the sea coast from Canada to the tip of South America and the Islands. Is this a purely spiritual connection or does this course through my DNA?
All of this, for me, just proves how deep my feelings of emotional connection. I've not always been comfortable with my extreme sensitivity and have lamented on being somehow cursed. It's scary and uncomfortable, or at least, was more so in the past. I'm starting to let it be a part of me and not hide it or be embarrassed by it. It's not easy! I like things in a neat, explainable box, but these were not the cards I was dealt.
This journey has been a fascinating roller coaster that I am beginning to love more and more.
How about you? What fears keep you from sharing your experiences?
Saturday, August 19, 2017
You can run, but you can't hide!
With the attack at Charlottesville recently, it's interesting to see news about white supremacist looking to DNA testing to prove their "whiteness". You will, no doubt, in the near future hear these very same people denounce the findings of DNA because it doesn't serve their agenda. Good!
white-supremacists-have-stumbled-into-a-huge-issue-in-genetic-ancestry-testing/
Happily, for us all, DNA testing will only prove what we should all accept, we are an amalgam of everything and everyone. We are all brothers and sisters. The sooner we celebrate this the sooner our lives will be happier and content. So, even though I desperately seek every ancestor and every place those ancestors lived and died, I use this information to uncover history in it's truest form, with question marks. The truth is never easy, never black and white, never done by just a few heroes. Genealogy can help us work with historians to uncover the many layers of truth and mistakes.
As spiderman says, "with great power, there must also comes great responsibility"😎
white-supremacists-have-stumbled-into-a-huge-issue-in-genetic-ancestry-testing/
Happily, for us all, DNA testing will only prove what we should all accept, we are an amalgam of everything and everyone. We are all brothers and sisters. The sooner we celebrate this the sooner our lives will be happier and content. So, even though I desperately seek every ancestor and every place those ancestors lived and died, I use this information to uncover history in it's truest form, with question marks. The truth is never easy, never black and white, never done by just a few heroes. Genealogy can help us work with historians to uncover the many layers of truth and mistakes.
As spiderman says, "with great power, there must also comes great responsibility"😎
Friday, August 11, 2017
The Dead Files
Recently, I was hired to do some time sensitive research for the Travel Channel program "The Dead Files". While I can't discuss the details until after the program airs, sometime in December or January, it was a thrilling chase! Unfortunately, I was slated to appear on the show with Steve Dischiavi, but the research segment they had chosen to film got scrapped. It happens....
Before this I had never seen an episode of this show, so I did a cram viewing session. As you can see by my other posts on serendipity I have a leaning toward paranormal belief. The show is quite thorough at background genealogy and history research whether you are a believer or skeptic.
The one indisputable thing that I found eerie is how each house has proven unusual deaths, usually many over generations. For me, I felt a sense of these souls needing their stories to be told. This is what happens to me so very often. It was surprising to find I didn't feel uncomfortable at all with this research on unusual deaths, quite the contrary, my detective radar is still working on more findings.
The Dead Files
Before this I had never seen an episode of this show, so I did a cram viewing session. As you can see by my other posts on serendipity I have a leaning toward paranormal belief. The show is quite thorough at background genealogy and history research whether you are a believer or skeptic.
The one indisputable thing that I found eerie is how each house has proven unusual deaths, usually many over generations. For me, I felt a sense of these souls needing their stories to be told. This is what happens to me so very often. It was surprising to find I didn't feel uncomfortable at all with this research on unusual deaths, quite the contrary, my detective radar is still working on more findings.
The Dead Files
Sunday, August 6, 2017
LONG LOST FATHER FOUND INSTANTLY WITH DNA
The results were no less than
shocking! My friend grew up very close
to a mother who is Native American and a step father with step siblings. Looking kind of the part of an American native led his life to certain things being taken for granted. Also, his mother’s memory was of a possible Scottish descent for the father because he had red hair. So imagine his surprise when the test came back as 47% (50% of your DNA comes from each parent) Ashkenazi
Jew! What the…????
If that wasn’t enough of a
surprise, there was an aunt connection right off the bat through the same testing site! She responded immediately and said her
brother remembered the very short-lived relationship with his mom and really
wanted to talk to him. Wow!!! Lift jaw off of the floor...
Then…. the serendipity became
deep…. the biological father was in a VA hospital where he was diagnosed just weeks earlier with
stage 4 esophageal cancer, among other things, with a very bleak outcome. He had never married and had no other
children. If my friend was ever going to find his father, it HAD
to happen now…before it was too late. The father was so overwhelmed with joy to find out, not only did he have a son, but he had grandchildren! I’m blown away…..
My friend flew to
meet his father and get to know his long-lost Ashkenazi Jewish Heritage. He was able to spend days getting to know his father and extended family that flew in as well. 7 days after my friend left his father's side he passed. I cannot
fathom how he feels right now, very few of us can. But, this is more proof for me that there is
more at work here in this life than any of us can explain. My journey is to touch this path, discover
and tell these stories.
This came directly after
doing a fast-extensive research project for a TV show, soon to be shared in a post. Stay tuned….
Thursday, August 3, 2017
REPARATIONS
This
is a tough topic for me and has painted a large portion of my life. I
cannot explain the responsibility I feel to at minimum discuss my historical
past, and how knowing and witnessing this past will in some way help.
Maybe it just helps me, I don't know. But, I feel compelled to
express my view of reparation.
I
am American, British, Irish, Scottish, German, Swiss, French, Native American,
Scandinavian, Portuguese, Spainish, Sardinian, West African, and very far back
Turkish, Greek, and finally Neanderthal. You know what....that pretty
much covers the world. I am earth, yet I am not just one of the above, so
am I nothing?
On
one hand my ancestors served, on the other they destroyed. So...what does
reparation mean to me. What do I claim as my heritage? Does
only royal ancestry count? I have been told by certain genealogist,
yes…but alas, they are dead wrong.
I’ve
been seeing something within the Native American community that concern me,
that I see as the continuation of a pattern of destruction and suppression.
Recently, I’ve been seeing a lot of postings, with pictures, by people who
claim Native American heritage (the “Diluted”), who are subsequently accused of
not looking “native” by others who fear that their Native American heritage is being
stolen (the “Purists”). Purists condemn anyone who claim native heritage
without having been raised on a reservation, or has diluted blood (e.g., less
than 80% native blood). This does nothing for the Native community as a whole,
except exacerbate the pain and emptiness which already burden Purists. My
question to Purists is, “Do you really want to use the same tactics used by the
Aryan Race to destroy and suppress ‘mongrels’? The same tactics used by
White Supremacists?” Please....no....
I
understand why tribes have to have regulations for membership in a tribe,
because of recognition from the US government. That does not have to
influence treatment of those who just want to celebrate their heritage without
affecting tribal recognition, I know that can be a gray area sometimes, but
again, a small minority.
This
behavior is similar to what happens in the black community when someone with
"light" black skin color dares to claim his/her black
heritage even though s/he had a white mom or dad. In the 1800's, such
were listed on the census as "mulatto." This was and has never
been viewed as a positive term. It was often used to suppress, even within the
black community, traumatizing those who were ostracized by the very people who
should have embraced them. Many in the black community viewed mulattos as
“privileged,” because they could frequently pass as white. Some mulattos could
and did advance themselves with the help of white privilege. Would they
have been better off staying within the black community? Should they
have stayed within the black community and accepted the shame and isolation of
that choice? Why should Purists force a choice upon mulattos that
they themselves need never make?
How
do we heal inter-communal racism? Black, red, yellow…. It might be helpful to
first remember that there are no absolutes, only shades of gray, exemplified by
my own ancestry.
On
my mother's side (which is predominantly from the south and southwest), I
cannot find one direct ancestor that fought for the south in the civil war, nor
owned slaves, not one, yay, right? BUT, on my father's side, not only do
I have direct ancestors who fought for the south and owned slaves, I also have
two Native American chiefs (Werowances) whose progeny owned slaves (and possibly
the chiefs as well). (Yes, Native Americans in the south sometimes owned
slaves! I can delve into this for pages, but let's stay on point.)
Also
on my mother's side, I have a direct ancestor who, in his time, was a
well-known buffalo hunter in Kansas. He massacred an amazing number of
buffalo. It hasn't been proven yet, but his grandfather was adopted and
was believed to have been Native American.
Whites
who hunted buffalo and owned slaves. But also whites who didn’t own
slaves. And Native Americans who did own slaves! Who the hell am I? Do
I celebrate my white ancestry and feel ashamed of my Native American ancestry?
Or do I feel ashamed of them both? How should I reconcile such surprising
discrepancies? This is where, for me, reparation is important. I
learn about all of my ancestry. But more importantly, I honor all of
my ancestry – the good and the bad and, more frequently, the grey. I think
that it’s okay to feel a connection to my Native American ancestry even though
I look and am predominantly white. I do not take anything away
from anyone (including Purists) by doing this. I serve the buffalo by
showing their beauty to others in pictures on my Facebook page and elsewhere.
Someday I hope to put my hands on a buffalo and weep. This will heal me
and maybe even the buffalo. Or maybe just me, I don't know.
Elsewhere,
I honor my West African heritage by referring to my black friends as “my
brothers and sisters,” and by acting as witness to and shining the light on
racism through Facebook posts and discussions with those who don't get it. Does
this very small part of my DNA come from one of my slave owning ancestors?
Probably. I honor all of it. I acknowledge the beauty
and pride in us all and in all the heritages we represent. I do
everything I can to keep them alive regardless of the comprise in my own
ancestry. Do I do enough? Probably not, but I will continue to
honor and support every one of them in any way possible to help heal racism.
It takes nothing away from anyone to do so. How about you?
I
understand the desire to hold one’s heritage close, within one’s heart. That
is not permission, however, to push others away from their desire to also honor
history – history that is shared by both Diluted and Purists. Yes...you
can share. I know, there will always be those who will try to use
"heritage" to their advantage. But, really...what can they
gain? They are a very small minority. Should we let this small minority
deepen racial wounds? Why, when there is support and healing to be gained by
including everyone in honoring your heritage? I'm not here to tell
you what you should do. But I do urge you to consider your own role
in this spectrum. And I encourage you to share in the comments the ways in
which you act to help heal these old wounds.
I
started writing this article the day before reading about the UN
announcement last year (making the rounds again on Facebook) about it's
findings on US Slavery Reparations. Serendipitous this would find me
right as I was finishing the article. It's important to note that the
UN just had recommendations, no "orders"......
“a
formal apology, health initiatives, educational opportunities…psychological
rehabilitation, technology transfer and financial support, and debt
cancellation.”
Washington
Post article 2016
An amazing hero, Peter Norman showing what reparation is all about. Peter Norman
An amazing hero, Peter Norman showing what reparation is all about. Peter Norman
Clearly,
this won't happen. Here's a little history on slavery reparation for more
in-depth reading.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)